Resources Live Decision Tracker. Unknown 19 November at Unknown 30 October at Customized for You we will pick new questions that match your level based on your Timer History. This will help us suggest you relevant posts to you.
Admitted – Which School to Choose? Firstborn humans also produce relatively high levels of cortisol in stimulating situations such as return of a parent after an absence. In this case, the proposition of the writer would be flawed. Stratus Admissions Counseling Reviews. Posted by Unknown at Hence, the birth order may be relevant to some extent in the stimulation level of individuals.
The following appeared as part of a letter to the editor of a scientific journal.
Subscribe to Unlock Test Prep Material
However, there may be certain other factors that are more relevant than the birth order such as those discussed above. In the second case, mothers who had had several offspring could have learn t how to control hormone cortisol with their firstborn child.
Thus, the premise of the author might be easily critiqued. The main issue present in the article is that it mistakes the role of cortisol in the human body. The only time that this connection is drawn in the article is when it discusses the pregnancy of first time mother monkeys versus those with several offspring.
Since exprementing on only 18 monkeys is not much, and also there is no information about ruesus attributes of the unfamilair monkey and situations, the conclusion is not persuasive and the mentioned alternatives are all likely to be the reason.
In the second case, mothers who had had several offspring could have learn how to control hormone cortisol with their firstborn child. A sample size is generally a large number and should contain a wide variety of individuals.
Copyright material – Posting copyright material is strongly discouraged. This argument provides with some conclusions based on some study findings but lacks proper correlation between them.
What are the reasons to claim so? The argumet presents some observations to infer that first born monkeys usually have higher level of stimulation hormones than the next siblings.
May 23, 1: The underlying study of rhesus monkeys state that firstborn infant monkeys produce twice as much of the hormone cortisol as their siblings, when this evidence of eighteen monkey is unwarranted. High Court – Clerical.
You worked pretty good monkyes this task. Write a response in which you discuss one or more alternative esszy that could rival the proposed explanation and explain how your explanation s can plausibly account for the facts presented in the argument. Likewise, the stimulus considered in the argument is different for both the cases. The individual’s level of stimulation can be a result of not only a birth order, but also other factors.
You are commenting using your Google account.
Birth Order and Stimulation (Argumentative Task) | News Analysis for GMAT / GRE Essay Practice
The more advanced frontal lobe of the human might have a different relation among stimulating situations and cortisol production than that of monkeys. We noticed you are actually not timing your practice. But try to extend a little bit with this info. The argument could be strengthened if the editor provided information regarding other field as psychology. The study was concentrated only on one type of causation and there are a few fallacies and inaccuracies in the argument.
Please grade my essay! : Analytical Writing Assessment (AWA)
Though the hormone Cortisol is present in both the monkeys and humans, the stimulus in both the cases can be different. In the argument, the author only mention s monkey studies in stimulating situations and one study about firstborn human and pregnancy period It is nowhere mentioned in the passage that only one study was conducted so I recommend modifying that phrase to something like evidence for substantial studies of first born humans have not been shown thereby making the claim less convincing.
The following appeared as part of a letter to the editor of a scientific journal. So it may have happened that the given study might have been conducted on rhesus monkeys belonging to a specific location say Malaysia and this led to similar results leading to above observations.
Mmonkeys higher level of cortisol could have been caused by conditions in which the monkey was kept or the type of food which was given to her. The argument posits that a study of eighteen monkeys has found an increased level of Cortisol. These results can be varying in many different circumstances and an extensive study needs to be done to conclusively establish the above mentioned results with respect to birth order of offspring. Leave a Reply Cancel reply Enter your comment here It would have been more convincing if mokeys definition was broader and research done on more parameters to make the conclusion more concrete.
The second inference about generating more hormone when seeing a parent by older sibling is resus spported well. The upbringing of children can also be influential for such feedbacks.